Should party leaders, as opposed to voters, nominate candidates for special elections?

In the wake of Representative George Santos’ expulsion from Congress, Governor Kathy Hochul has issued a proclamation for a special election to fill the void. Scheduled for February 13, 2024, Hochul noted that this special election is set “to ensure the voters of Long Island and Queens once again have representation in Congress.”

Party leaders in Nassau County and Queens will pick the nominees without a primary. The race will be treated as a major bellwether in a traditional battleground corner of New York that Santos won with 54 percent of the vote in 2022. — The Hill Hochul sets special election to replace Santos for Feb. 13

George Santos’ tenure in Congress was marred by controversy and scandal, culminating in a bipartisan vote leading to his expulsion. The expulsion, a rare occurrence in the U.S. House of Representatives, was the result of a string of federal charges including fraud and campaign finance violations. The allegations against Santos included fraudulent activities aimed at enriching his political ambitions and a slew of other charges ranging from wire fraud to making false statements to Congress. This drastic measure by the House reflects the gravity of the accusations and the erosion of trust in Santos’ ability to represent his constituents.

In the upcoming special election to fill Santos’ seat, candidates will be nominated by party leaders rather than chosen through a primary election by the voters. This process has its advocates and critics. Proponents argue that it ensures a swift and efficient selection of candidates, crucial for maintaining governance and representation. On the other hand, critics point out that it circumvents the democratic process, denying voters the opportunity to directly influence their representation. The winner of this special election will only serve for the remainder of the year, with the next standard election scheduled for November.

The democratic process is fundamentally about voter leadership and representation. However, the urgency to fill congressional vacancies can sometimes necessitate a more expedient approach. While having party leaders nominate candidates expedites the process, it also raises questions about democratic ideals and voter participation. As we continue to strive to uphold the basis of a representative government, it is essential to contemplate the implications of such a nomination process.

What’s your opinion? Do you believe that party leaders, as opposed to voters, should continue to nominate candidates for special elections?

Additional:

• Reforming the special election process with political consultant Andrey Bystrov
• Governor Hochul Issues Proclamation for Special Election to Replace George Santos
• With George Santos out of Congress, special election to fill his New York seat is set for February
• Why was George Santos expelled from the House? Here are the charges and allegations against him
•  Hochul sets special election to replace Santos for Feb. 13

---

Nuance with Mike Scala and Jay Carter is a weekly video podcast that engages its audience through examination of current events from the unique perspectives of its hosts and guests.

→ SUBSCRIBE TO Nuance with Mike Scala and Jay Carter ←
Subscribe: Nuance with Mike Scala and Jay Carter
The podcast is available on Spotify and all major podcast outlets.